Get A Free Payroll Quote

Smarter Payroll Alternative

Outgrowing Smarter Payroll?
Switch to Premier Payroll for Transparent Pricing and Real Support.

Smarter Payroll and Paychex have been around for years but small business owners often say the same things:

  • It’s too complicated.
  • The pricing keeps changing.
  • I can never reach support when I need help.

Book A Free Consultation

By submitting, you agree to a friendly follow‑up with no obligation.

If that sounds familiar, you’re in the right place.

Premier Payroll Services is the Smarter Payroll alternative that delivers what small businesses really need:

Transparent pricing

Faster payroll runs

Real, human support

Smarter Payroll vs Premier Payroll: A Clear Comparison

Problem

Premier Payroll

Smarter Payroll

Ease of Use

Simple, modern dashboard for everyone

Outdated interface; steep
learning curve

Pricing Transparency

Flat, published pricing with no add-ons

Get a quote” model; unclear costs

Customer Support

Dedicated payroll specialist, available anytime

Tiered, limited hours

Onboarding Time

Get up and running in days

1–2 weeks

Tax Filing

Included in all plans

Add-on cost for some tiers

Integrations

Seamless integrations with QuickBooks, Xero, POS & HR tools

Basic accounting sync only

Contract Terms

Month-to-month, cancel anytime

Long-term or annual

Talk to a Payroll Expert

Why Businesses Are Switching from Smarter Payroll to Premier Payroll

1.Ransparent Pricing — No Surprises

Searching for “SurePayroll cost” or “SurePayroll pricing” online?


You’ll rarely find numbers.
Premier Payroll believes in open, honest pricing — published, predictable, and all-inclusive.

2.Simple, Intuitive Payroll Runs

SurePayroll’s workflows can be confusing and time-consuming.

With Premier Payroll, you can run payroll in just 3 clicks, with real-time error checks and instant tax calculations.

3.Real Human Support — Always

Tired of chatbots or long hold times?


At Premier, you get a dedicated account manager who knows your business — not a rotating support queue.

4.All-Inclusive Payroll. No Hidden Add-Ons.

SurePayroll and Paychex charge extra for tax filings, benefits, and compliance help.
Premier Payroll gives you everything in one simple price — from automated filings to HR assistance.

What You Get With Premier Payroll

Everything ADP promises — only faster, simpler, and more personal.

Unlimited Payroll Runs

Automatic Tax Filings (Federal, State, Local)

Direct Deposits & W-2/1099s

Employee Self-Service Portal

Time & Attendance Integration

HR Templates
& Expert Guidance

Talk to a Payroll Expert

Reviews Breakdown

Premier Payroll Solutions (NY)

Smarter Payroll

5.0/5

NA

A+ Rating

A+ Rating

4.8/5

1.15/5

1.7/5

Overall Review

4.8/5

2.3

SurePayroll Pricing vs Premier Payroll Pricing

No “get a quote.” No surprise bills. Just clarity.

Premier Payroll Pricing:

  • Transparent flat pricing: starts at $39/month + $6 per employee
  • Taxes, filings, and support included
  • No contract lock-ins — cancel anytime

Smarter Payroll Pricing:

  • Hidden fees for tax filing
  • Extra charge for contractor pay
  • Price varies by plan & location
  • Annual contracts required

Why Premier Payroll Is the Smarter Payroll Alternative Businesses Trust

Because we’re built for you — small business owners who want:

  • Simple tools
  • Honest pricing
  • Reliable human support

If you’re tired of paying for complexity, it’s time to switch to the SurePayroll competitor that works harder for you.

Book A Free Consultation

By submitting, you agree to a friendly follow‑up with no obligation.

FAQs

1. Is Premier Payroll a Smarter Payroll competitor?

Yes. Premier Payroll offers full-service payroll, tax filing, and HR support with simpler workflows and clearer pricing.

2. How does Premier Payroll’s cost compare to Smarter Payroll pricing?

Paychex is built for scalability, but many small businesses find it too complex and costly. Premier Payroll is designed for small to mid-sized companies and offers more personalized support at a lower cost.

3. Can I migrate from Smarter Payroll easily?

Yes. Paychex is better suited for larger businesses with complex HR needs, while Premier Payroll is a better fit for small to mid-sized companies that want fast, reliable, and affordable payroll services.

4. Is Premier Payroll reliable for compliance and taxes?

Yes. Paychex is better suited for larger businesses with complex HR needs, while Premier Payroll is a better fit for small to mid-sized companies that want fast, reliable, and affordable payroll services.

See Why Businesses Choose Premier Payroll Over Smarter Payroll

Transparent. Reliable. Human.

Stop overpaying for payroll software that doesn’t fit your business.

Get a demo, compare your costs, and make the switch today.

Book a Demo
See Pricing
Scroll to Top