#1 Toast Payroll Competitor in NY
Skip the Toast. Get the Real Payroll Pros.
When you compare industry leaders side-by-side, small businesses get a payroll solution with added value when they choose Premier Payroll NY.
At Premier Payroll Services, we built a better, more human payroll experience with transparent pricing, dedicated support, and cloud-based automation that just works.
Request Pricing
By submitting, you agree to a friendly follow‑up with no obligation.
Powerful Payroll. Human Support. Zero Nonsense.
Transparent pricing
No hidden add-ons
Dedicated support
Real people, not call queues
Fast onboarding
Go live in days, not weeks
Built for Small Businesses Not Just Restaurants
Unlike Toast Payroll, which locks you into their ecosystem, Premier Payroll NY gives you the freedom to manage payroll your way:
- Run unlimited payrolls anytime
- Automate taxes, filings, and compliance
- Pay W-2 & 1099 employees
- Sync time and attendance
- Get real HR guidance from experts
Whether you’re switching from My Toast Payroll, Paychex, or ADP, we make it easy to move your data and start fresh quickly and securely.
Getting Started with Premier Payroll is easy. Sign up today and Get FREE Consultation
See the terms and conditions
Why Premier Payroll NY is the leading choice over Toast Payroll
Features
Clear, upfront monthly pricing with no surprise charges, hidden fees, or per-call support costs.
Ease of Use
Support from a payroll specialist via phone & email, at no additional fee
Seamless integrations with time-tracking, HR, accounting, and POS systems to keep all operations synced.
Restaurants, retail, healthcare, contractors, etc Industries Supported
Month-to-month plans with zero long-term lock-ins.
Successful Businesses Who Have Put Their Trust In Us
Toast Payroll vs Premier Payroll Reviews
Reviews Breakdown
5/5
4.8/5
A+ Rating
N/A
4.8/5
3.8/5
N/A
N/A
Why Businesses Switch from Toast Payroll to Premier Payroll
Problem
Premier Payroll
Toast Payroll
Pricing Transparency
Flat monthly pricing, visible upfront
Hidden fees; custom quotes
Setup Time
Simple onboarding for all industries
Complex restaurant setup
Support
Dedicated payroll specialist
Limited live help
Integrations
Connects with QuickBooks, Xero, POS & HR tools
Works mainly within Toast
Industries Supported
Restaurants, retail, healthcare, contractors, more
Restaurants only
Contract Term
Month-to-month flexibility
Long-term commitments
Simple, Transparent Pricing No Surprises
If you’re searching for “Toast Payroll cost” or “Toast Payroll pricing” and can’t find a clear answer you’re not alone.
No extra fees. No hidden “restaurant-only” limits.
Starter Plan
$39
/per month
+ $6 per employee
- Payroll processing
- Tax filings
- Direct deposit
- W-2/1099 support
- HR guidance
Growth Plan
$79
/per month
+ $8 per employee
- Payroll processing
- Tax filings
- Direct deposit
- W-2/1099 support
- HR guidance
Scale Plan
$39
/per month
+ $10 per employee
- Payroll processing
- Tax filings
- Direct deposit
- W-2/1099 support
- HR guidance
Get valuable HR & Payroll tools included only with Premier Payroll NY
Request Quote to get the Best Toast Payroll Alternative.
See how easy it is to take control with Premier Payroll NY.
Get A Free Demo
By submitting, you agree to a friendly follow‑up with no obligation.
Top FAQs about Premier Payroll NY vs. Toast Payroll
The key difference is flexibility: Premier Payroll allows you to “run unlimited payrolls … manage payroll your way,” without locking you into a fixed ecosystem. Toast Payroll, in contrast, is more tightly integrated with its POS and broader restaurant-management system.
Small businesses may prefer Premier Payroll because it’s described as more affordable, transparent, and “small-business-friendly.” Meanwhile, Toast Payroll tends to be more suitable for businesses already embedded in its POS or needing cohesive POS-Payroll integration.
Yes. According to the comparison, Premier Payroll doesn’t lock you into a predefined ecosystem. You retain the freedom to manage payroll “your way.”In other words, it offers more flexibility if you use different tools for POS, accounting, or other operations.
Yes. The Premier Payroll offering explicitly mentions “unlimited” payroll runs, implying no extra charge or cap per pay period. For businesses that need frequent payroll cycles (weekly, bi-weekly), that can be a significant advantage compared to software that charges per run or limits runs.
Toast Payroll tends to be better suited for restaurants or businesses already using (or planning to use) Toast’s POS and restaurant-management system. Its strength lies in integrated payroll + POS + operations which works best if you want a unified, all-in-one system.
Before switching, consider whether you rely heavily on POS-payroll integration, tip management, or restaurant-specific workflows. If you do, Toast Payroll’s unified system might offer convenience. If, instead, you value flexibility, simplicity, transparent pricing, and frequent payroll runs Premier Payroll might better suit your needs.