Compare top Long Island payroll providers with expert analysis, detailed feature breakdowns, and real business insights, empowering you to choose the perfect payroll solution for your company
Premier Payroll NY provides payroll, HR, benefits administration, and timekeeping solutions with a personalized touch. Clients praise its reliability and customer service, especially in the restaurant sector. Trusted by 550+ businesses, they combine robust software with a “people-first” approach, ensuring that technical solutions are backed by expert customer support.
41 reviews
Tell us more about your business and we will send you the details
*We will mail you the list in a jiffy.. And don’t worry, we never share your info with anyone
Finding the right payroll provider requires a deep, data-driven evaluation. Our team carefully assesses key factors to ensure you get the most reliable, efficient, and cost-effective payroll solutions.
The service must handle payroll processing with precision and stay compliant with tax laws.
A user-friendly interface with intuitive navigation makes payroll management smoother.
The payroll provider should cater to businesses of all sizes, from startups to large enterprises.
Reliable and responsive support ensures you get help when you need it.
The service should offer direct deposit, tax filing, employee self-service, and integrations with accounting software.
Clear and upfront pricing helps businesses avoid unexpected fees.
We analyze customer feedback and industry reputation to gauge trustworthiness.
Strong data security measures protect sensitive payroll information.
Payroll service providers do more than just process paychecks. They offer a range of solutions designed to simplify workforce management and ensure compliance.
Here’s what you can expect
Automates salary calculations, tax deductions, and direct deposits for employees.
Ensures payroll taxes are calculated, filed, and paid accurately to avoid penalties.
Allows employees to access pay stubs, tax documents, and update their details online.
Integrates with timekeeping systems to ensure accurate payroll calculations.
Manages employee benefits, health insurance, retirement plans, and onboarding.
Handles legal deductions such as child support or debt repayments.
Helps businesses manage compliance and reporting for workplace injury claims.
Provides insights into payroll costs, tax liabilities, and workforce trends.
Payroll processing is the system businesses use to calculate employee wages, deduct taxes, and ensure timely payments. It involves tracking work hours, calculating earnings, withholding deductions, and filing payroll taxes. A reliable payroll service automates these tasks, ensuring compliance with tax laws while saving businesses time and reducing errors.
Payroll companies streamline and automate the process of paying employees while ensuring tax compliance. Here’s how they operate:
Businesses provide details such as salaries, work hours, tax information, and benefits.
The provider calculates gross wages, tax withholdings, benefits deductions, and net pay.
Payroll companies handle federal, state, and local tax deductions and ensure timely filings.
Employees receive wages via direct deposit, printed checks, or payroll cards.
Businesses access payroll reports for financial tracking, audits, and compliance.
Many providers offer online portals for employees to view pay stubs, tax forms, and benefits.
Most payroll companies handle everything from processing employee salaries and tax withholdings to direct deposits and end-of-year tax forms. Some also offer extra features like benefits management, HR tools, and time-tracking integrations.
New York has some pretty strict payroll and tax laws, so good payroll providers stay on top of updates to make sure businesses don’t run into compliance issues. They handle things like tax filings, overtime calculations, and workers’ comp to keep everything above board.
New York payroll laws are complex, and Long Island businesses often have unique needs. A provider with local experience will understand regional tax rules, industry-specific requirements, and the best way to handle payroll for businesses operating in Nassau and Suffolk counties.
Most payroll companies take care of tax deductions, withholdings, and filings for federal, state, and local taxes. They’ll also send out W-2s and 1099s to employees and contractors. Some even offer tax penalty protection if they make a mistake.
It depends on the provider and the features included. Some charge a flat monthly fee, while others have per-employee pricing. Expect to pay anywhere from $30 to $150 per month, plus a small fee per employee.
Since payroll involves a lot of sensitive employee information, top providers use encryption, multi-factor authentication, and secure cloud storage to protect data. If security is a big concern, it’s worth asking about their safety measures before signing up.
Yes, most payroll companies offer integrations with popular accounting software like QuickBooks and Xero, as well as HR platforms for things like benefits and time tracking. If you already use a specific tool, check if the payroll provider supports it.
It varies. Some providers offer 24/7 live support with dedicated account managers, while others rely on email or chatbots. If payroll issues stress you out, going with a company that offers real human support can save you a lot of headaches.
Most good payroll companies have reviews from other businesses. Checking Google Reviews, Yelp, and the Better Business Bureau (BBB) can help gauge how reliable they are. Some also provide case studies or client references upon request.
Yes, but not all providers are set up for multi-state payroll. If you have remote employees or offices outside New York, make sure your payroll company can handle compliance in multiple locations.
Many payroll companies offer HR tools, benefits administration, 401(k) management, workers’ comp, and even compliance assistance. If you want more than just paycheck processing, look for a provider with add-ons that fit your business needs.
It depends on your current provider and how the new one handles onboarding. Some services make it easy by migrating your data for you, while others require manual setup. If you’re switching mid-year, make sure all past payroll records transfer correctly.
Yes, most payroll services can grow with your business. Whether you’re hiring your first employee or managing a large team, it’s a good idea to choose a provider that offers flexible plans and features you may need down the road.
Some providers offer onboarding training, video tutorials, and dedicated account reps to walk you through the system. Others are more DIY. If you’re new to payroll, look for a provider that offers solid training and support.
Most reputable providers have compliance teams that monitor tax laws and labor regulations. They update their systems automatically, so businesses don’t have to worry about legal changes affecting payroll.
Payroll companies process payments for both employees and 1099 contractors, handling tax forms and ensuring compliance. Some offer direct deposit and automated tax reporting for contractors.
If there’s a mistake—like an incorrect paycheck amount or tax miscalculation—most payroll providers have error correction policies. Some offer guarantees where they’ll fix mistakes for free, while others may charge extra. It’s a good idea to check their policy on corrections before signing up.
The time varies by provider, but most payroll companies process payments within 1-2 business days. Some offer same-day or next-day payroll processing for an additional fee. If quick payroll turnaround is important, look for a provider that supports faster payouts.
Yes, some providers specialize in industries like restaurants, construction, healthcare, or retail, offering features tailored to industry-specific needs.
Most businesses run payroll weekly, biweekly, or monthly. The best schedule depends on cash flow, industry standards, and employee expectations.
